When new technology replaces goods covered by a trademark, does use for the newer products count as "genuine use"? The French Court of Cassation's Zoom ruling
On 12 November 2026, the French Court of Cassation issued a judgment in a dispute concerning the revocation of the French trademark "Zoom" for non-use. The judgment provides several important clarifications concerning genuine trademark use, but its treatment of technological developments is particularly interesting. The Court held that use of a trademark for newer products does not establish genuine use for the goods originally registered merely because technological developments have led the newer products to replace them.

On 12 November 2026, the French Court of Cassation issued a judgment in a trademark dispute between Zoom Communications and the Japanese company Kabushiki Kaisha Zoom concerning the revocation of the latter's French trademark "Zoom" for non-use.
The judgment provides several important clarifications concerning genuine trademark use, but its treatment of technological developments is particularly interesting. The Court held that where technological progress has led to new products that take the place of the goods originally registered, using the trademark for those successor products does not in itself amount to genuine use for the original goods. For example, a company that registered a trademark for tape recorders but now uses it exclusively for digital sound recorders cannot assume that such use will preserve its trademark rights for the originally registered goods.
Background
The Japanese company Kabushiki Kaisha Zoom (KKZ) owns the French word trademark "Zoom" for various products, including "sound recording devices", "outdoor sound systems", "computer graphics creation and editing systems", and "tape recorders".
In 2021, the American company Zoom Communications, known for its videoconferencing services, sought revocation of KKZ's trademark on the grounds of non-use.
The French Intellectual Property Office (INPI) rejected the request, and the Paris Court of Appeal upheld that decision in July 2024. Zoom Communications subsequently appealed to the Court of Cassation.
The Court of Cassation partially quashed the Paris Court of Appeal's judgment in relation to the four categories of goods mentioned above and referred the case back to a differently constituted Court of Appeal. The judgment provides several important clarifications concerning genuine trademark use.
Genuine use of a trademark must relate to the goods specified in its registration (here, "tape recorders"), even where other goods have subsequently replaced them because of technological developments (here, digital sound recorders)
Perhaps the most interesting aspect of the judgment concerns the impact of technological developments on genuine trademark use.
KKZ's trademark was registered for "tape recorders", traditionally understood as devices that record sound on magnetic tape. However, to demonstrate genuine use of the trademark for these goods, KKZ relied on evidence of its use for digital sound recorders. The Paris Court of Appeal accepted this evidence, reasoning that technological developments had led digital sound recorders to replace traditional tape recorders.
The Court of Cassation disagreed. It held that genuine use of a trademark must relate to the goods specified in its registration, rather than other goods, even where technological developments have led the latter to replace the former. Consequently, KKZ's use of the trademark for digital sound recorders did not establish genuine use for the registered goods, "tape recorders".
The specific wording of the registered goods matters (here, the word "outdoor" in "outdoor sound systems")
KKZ's trademark was registered for "outdoor sound systems". KKZ demonstrated use for sound equipment, including microphones, mixing consoles, amplifiers and computer audio interfaces, which was accepted by the Paris Court of Appeal as sufficient for genuine use.
However, the Court of Cassation found that the Court of Appeal had failed to examine whether the equipment for which KKZ had demonstrated use was actually intended for outdoor use, a necessary condition for falling within the registered category of "outdoor sound systems".
Use of a trademark for specific goods (here, portable sound recorders) does not necessarily establish genuine use for a broader registered category (here, "sound recording devices")
KKZ's trademark covered "sound recording devices", but its evidence of genuine use concerned portable sound recorders. The Paris Court of Appeal considered this sufficient to establish genuine use for "sound recording devices" as a category.
Zoom Communications had argued that portable sound recorders constituted an autonomous subcategory. The Court of Cassation held that the Court of Appeal should have examined whether that is the case. Although the available decision does not explicitly explain why this distinction matters, it follows from established CJEU case law (ACTC v EUIPO, C-714/18 P, and Ferrari, Joined Cases C-720/18 and C-721/18) that where a registered category contains distinct, autonomous subcategories, genuine use for one subcategory does not necessarily preserve trademark protection for the others. Therefore, to establish genuine use for the entire registered category, the trademark owner must demonstrate genuine use for each of its distinct, autonomous subcategories.
The Court of Cassation held that the Court of Appeal should have assessed it based on objective criteria, primarily by reference to the purpose and intended use of the goods.
Genuine use must be demonstrated for goods falling within the registered category (here, "computer graphics creation and editing systems"), not merely for related products (here, audio-recording and editing applications)
KKZ's trademark covered "computer graphics creation and editing systems". To establish genuine use for these goods, KKZ relied on its "Handy Recorder" and "Handy Recorder PRO" applications. The Paris Court of Appeal accepted this evidence, reasoning that the registered category could include applications allowing sound files to be displayed and edited in graphical form.
However, Zoom Communications argued that these applications belonged to a different category of goods and that their use could not establish genuine use for "computer graphics creation and editing systems". The Court of Cassation held that the Paris Court of Appeal had failed to address this argument and had therefore insufficiently reasoned its judgment, in violation of Article 455 of the French Code of Civil Procedure.
Comment
The judgment offers two practical lessons for trademark owners.
First, trademark owners should periodically review their registrations to ensure that the descriptions of goods reflect the products for which their trademarks are actually used. This is particularly important in sectors where technology evolves rapidly. Where technological developments lead to new products that are not covered by existing registrations, filing new trademark applications may be necessary.
Second, the judgment highlights the importance of carefully choosing the descriptions of goods when applying for registration. While broad categories may offer certain advantages, trademark owners should bear in mind that use of a trademark for one type of product may not be sufficient to prove genuine use for the entire category.
(05) - Knowledge hub
All insightsCan you avoid mass-redundancy obligations with termination agreements?
Serbia’s new rules on online consumer reviews: lessons from Italy’s guidelines
EU Pay Transparency Directive and equal pay in Serbia: what employers need to know
Can you DocuSign employment agreements, dismissal documents, and other employment-related documents?
Employee side projects: when can employers claim copyright?

